Article content

Sharing our CEO, Samantha Allen‘s final instalment in CAS’s What We’re Engaging with series. In this final piece, she reflects on Bernice L. McFadden’s Sugar – a powerful novel about what happens when a woman is never given the freedom to define herself.

The piece also interweaves the lives and legacies of Betye Saar, Gloria Steinem and Dolly Parton, each of whom resisted easy categorisation and, in very different ways, shaped an identity on their own terms. Following reflections on Frida Kahlo and Grace Jones, this final instalment brings the series’ central question into sharp focus: who gets to decide who a woman is, and what does belonging to oneself and to others truly mean.

Read the full piece below!

Over the last two weeks, I’ve been thinking about women and the ownership of identity. I began with Frida Kahlo, and what can happen when a woman who spent her lifetime so deliberately defining herself is no longer here to control what happens to that image. Then came Grace Jones: still here, still evolving, still refusing to be reduced to a single, manageable version of herself.

Frida made me think about what happens when other people take ownership of a woman’s image. Grace made me think about what it looks like when a woman remains firmly in charge of it. And this week, Bernice L. McFadden’s Sugar takes that question somewhere more intimate: what happens when a woman is never given the freedom to define herself in the first place?

That question has felt especially present recently. In the space of a few weeks we have lost Betye Saar, Gloria Steinem and Dolly Parton, three extraordinary women who, in very different ways, spent decades creating work, identities and public lives that resisted easy categorisation.

Betye Saar spent more than seven decades making art that confronted race, gender and representation. She took racist images that had been used to diminish Black people, particularly Black women, and transformed them into objects of resistance, liberation and power. Even when the wider art world was slow to give her the recognition she deserved, she continued making work on her own terms well into her nineties.

Gloria Steinem built a public life around refusing the roles women were expected to accept. Through her writing, activism and organising, she helped reshape conversations, and remained a recognisable voice within the feminist movement for decades. As a nonagenarian, passing away at 92, :She continued to speak, write and campaign into later life, showing how a woman can retain ownership of her ideas, her politics and her public identity over time.

Article content

And Dolly Parton always fascinated me for a similar reason to Grace Jones: she seemed to understand exactly who she was. She could be sexual and deeply religious, funny and incredibly smart, glamorous and commercially astute, all at the same time. She never seemed interested in choosing between those parts of herself.

There is one story about Dolly that I keep coming back to. As a child, the woman she thought was the most beautiful person in town was the woman everyone else dismissed as the “town tramp”. Dolly saw the peroxide hair, red nails, lipstick, high heels and short skirt and thought she was magnificent. What other people regarded as shameful, Dolly saw as beautiful, and eventually folded into an image that became unmistakably her own. That detail feels almost uncanny alongside Sugar.

Bernice L. McFadden’s Sugar is, at its heart, a story about women trying to reclaim themselves in a world that has already decided who they are. Set in a small town in Arkansas, the novel centres on Sugar, a young woman who arrives carrying an identity that immediately unsettles the community. She is beautiful, sexual, independent and unapologetically different. Almost instantly, she becomes the town’s fascination:  an oddity to be discussed, watched and judged. And then they discover she is a prostitute.

Suddenly, the fascination becomes something much more threatening. Sugar is no longer simply the unusual young woman everyone is talking about or gaping at. She becomes a danger to the wives of the town, a perceived threat to marriages and morality, and someone who must be judged and contained. What is striking is how little space Sugar is given to simply be a person. The town constructs an identity for her, and then responds to that identity rather than to the woman herself.

The novel opens with the discovery of Pearl’s daughter’s murder, but Pearl really comes into focus when Sugar moves into the long-empty house next door. While the town gossips, Pearl is genuinely curious about her and wants to know who she really is. Pearl is almost the opposite of Sugar. A church-going woman who has been devastated by the murder and sexual mutilation of her young daughter fifteen years earlier, she has been living in a kind of emotional paralysis ever since. She is still physically present in the world, but a shadow of the woman she once was.

The relationship between these two women becomes the emotional heart of the novel. Through Sugar, Pearl begins to come back to life. Through Pearl, Sugar begins to rediscover something of her own humanity, sexuality and perhaps most importantly, a sense of belonging. Neither woman has experienced that feeling for a very long time.

Article content

Through Sugar, Pearl begins to come back to life. Through Pearl, Sugar begins to rediscover something of her own humanity and, perhaps most importantly, a sense of belonging. She begins to reconnect with her own sexuality: dressing up again, allowing herself to feel desirable and restarting a physical relationship with her loving and remarkably patient husband. Neither woman has experienced that sense of connection, to another person or to herself, for a very long time.

Their relationship creates a space in which they can see one another differently from the way the rest of the town sees them. Sugar is no longer simply the prostitute. Pearl is no longer simply the grieving mother. They become complicated, funny, rebellious, loving human beings.

Their relationship creates a space in which they can see one another differently from the way the rest of the town sees them. Sugar is no longer simply the prostitute. Pearl is no longer simply the grieving mother. Pearl encourages Sugar to pursue her passion for singing, helping her imagine a life in which she can be known for something other than the identity the town has assigned to her. Sugar begins singing regularly in public and is loved and admired for her talent. Together, they become complicated, funny, rebellious and loving human beings, capable of becoming more than the roles other people have reduced them to.

For a while, they are allowed to be their fullest selves. But the town has other ideas. And this is what stayed with me most about Sugar: who gets to decide who a woman is?

The community has created identities for both women and expects them to remain inside them. Sugar is the sexual threat. Pearl is the grieving mother. Neither is permitted to move beyond the role that has been assigned to her.Their friendship threatens that order because they begin to reclaim parts of themselves that the community would rather keep buried.

This connects strongly with the questions I found myself asking about Frida Kahlo and Grace Jones: how does a woman retain ownership of her own identity when everyone else wants to define her? But Sugar takes the question somewhere darker.

Article content

Frida consciously created an image of herself that resisted the identities imposed upon her. Grace Jones continues to author and perform her identity on her own terms. Betye Saar could take the stereotypes used against Black women and physically remake them into something defiant. Dolly Parton took an image other people associated with shame and made it part of an identity she controlled. Sugar does not have that same freedom or power.

She has no institution, stage, body of celebrated work or carefully constructed public image through which to answer back. Her identity is constructed for her by the people around her. They see her sexuality and decide they understand her. They give her a role, and then punish her for occupying it.

Pearl is trapped differently. She has almost disappeared beneath the identity of her grief. The community can understand her as a grieving mother; what becomes harder for them to accept is the idea that she might become something else again.

Both women have to find their way back to themselves through their relationship with one another. And perhaps that is what belonging ultimately means in this novel. Not simply being accepted by a community, but finding somewhere, and someone, with whom you are able to exist without being reduced to a single version of yourself.

What happens when the people around you refuse to let you become more than the person they have decided you are? Can you belong to yourself when your community refuses to accept the fullest version of who you are? And perhaps most painfully: what does it take for a woman to reclaim herself after other people have taken ownership of her story?

McFadden writes all of this with extraordinary tenderness. The writing is exquisite and captivating — lyrical without losing its brutality, and deeply intimate in the way it allows us to inhabit the inner lives of these women. What makes Sugar so powerful is that it is not really a story about a prostitute and a grieving mother.

If you’re looking to buy any of the books mentioned here, consider ordering through independent Black-owned booksellers such as Afrori Books or New Beacon Books. Across these three pieces, I keep coming back to the same question from different directions.

Frida made me ask who controls a woman’s image once she is no longer here to defend it. Grace made me ask what it looks like to keep authoring yourself as you age, refusing to become smaller or simpler for other people. Sugar asks something more fundamental: what if the people around you refuse to let you belong to yourself in the first place? Perhaps that is where identity and belonging meet.

Belonging is not simply being accepted into someone else’s version of who you should be. It is having the freedom to become more than the identity other people have assigned to you — and to be seen in all of your complexity when you do.

For a brief time, Sugar and Pearl give one another that freedom. They belong to themselves.

And that feels both beautiful and devastating.