
When Yuko Kikuchi left her role as the Victoria and Albert Museum’s Head of Academic Programmes in January, she released a whistleblowing statement, drafted the previous winter, that gained public attention after a July interview with The Art Newspaper (1). Reflecting on her time at one of the UK’s leading cultural institutions, she described pervasive systemic racism and the isolation of being “the only non-white person in the room”. Students echoed her concerns, contrasting the museum’s visible image of inclusion and diversification with the “imperialistic and colonial origins” they felt remained unmistakably at its core.
This, of course, isn’t a story about one museum or one person’s experience. The V&A is simply the latest institution to expose a question the cultural sector has yet to answer: what became of the commitments to equity and anti-racism that so many cultural organisations made in the wake of 2020? The V&A itself made explicit commitments then. In Black Lives Matter: Race and Equality at the V&A (2), director Tristram Hunt acknowledged the need to confront “unspoken racism” across the museum, from its workforce and programming to its collections and interpretation. Recognising the V&A as “a museum born of the colonial moment”, he promised greater urgency in addressing its colonial history and amplifying Black and minority voices.
The gap between those promises and Kikuchi’s account six years later is the central question. Black Lives Matter began in 2013 in response to systemic police violence, but George Floyd’s murder in 2020 made it a catalyst for collective action across the cultural sector. In the arts, this crystallised through #BlackoutTuesday (3), which grew from #TheShowMustBePaused, Jamila Thomas and Brianna Agyemang’s call for the music industry to pause business as usual and confront its relationship to racism. As the action spread beyond the industry, it helped prompt wider commitments on workforce and board diversity, anti-racism and programming across arts and heritage.
Nesrine Malik (4) argues that, as Black Lives Matter was absorbed by corporations and institutions, a movement concerned with police brutality, structural racism and the safety of Black communities was flattened into a question of representation. The institutional response focused on bringing more Black people into existing structures rather than asking whether those structures needed to change. Racial equality, she argues, requires not simply expansion but a rebalancing of resources, authority and decision-making power.
Sara Ahmed’s (5) work on institutional non-performativity sharpens this critique: an organisation’s anti-racist commitments can become evidence of virtue even when its practices and power remain unchanged. Visibility matters, but so does who controls it: who commissions artists, collects histories, promotes staff and decides which forms of cultural knowledge have legitimacy. Greater visibility for Black artists and cultural workers is important, but it is not the same as redistributing the power to decide who is seen, supported and valued.
The wider evidence suggests why this distinction matters. The Fawcett Society and Runnymede Trust’s Broken Ladders research (6) found that 61% of women of colour reported changing themselves to “fit in” at work, while 42% said they had been passed over for promotion despite receiving good feedback, compared with 27% of white women. The TUC’s research tells a similar story: 41% of Black and minority ethnic workers surveyed had experienced racism at work within the previous five years, while four in five of those affected did not report it. Access, progression and belonging, in other words, are not the same thing.
Olúfẹ́mi O. Táíwò’s discussion of value capture (8) explains how complex political goals can be reduced to measurable proxies until the proxy stands in for the goal itself. Racial equity is difficult to quantify, while representation and visibility are easier. Organisations can count Black and minoritised people on boards, in senior roles, exhibitions and programmes. These things matter, but the danger comes when their presence is treated as proof of transformation. Care must also be an institutional practice, visible in whether organisations notice harm, respond before crisis and accept responsibility for the conditions they create. The scrutiny surrounding Professor Jason Arday (9), his resignation from Cambridge and his unexpected death in August 2026 make the absence of such care an urgent public question.
Táíwò also connects this to elite capture: representation within existing positions of power does not necessarily redistribute that power or transform the structures beneath it. Representation itself remains unevenly distributed through institutional hierarchies. Byrne and Ali (10) found that ethnically diverse staff made up around 6–7% of the workforce in Arts Council England-funded museums between 2018 and 2020, but only 3–4% at management level, with minoritised staff clustered at the lower end of pay and seniority. They describe this as the “endurance of whiteness within museums”. Tate’s workforce ethnicity data (11) provides useful transparency, but seniority and decision-making power remain the more telling tests.
Sara Ahmed (5) identified this tension in 2006, nearly two decades before the commitments of 2020, asking who institutions are “shaped for and who [they are] shaped by.” Her idea of “diversity as an institutional performance” describes organisations that articulate commitments to equity without changing the structures and cultures through which power operates. Equality offers people the same resources or opportunities; equity recognises that unequal starting points and structural barriers require different support, resources and changes to power. The distinction is still too often blurred, allowing equal treatment to reproduce unequal outcomes. Read alongside the V&A’s promises, Ahmed’s warning remains pertinent: diversity work can change perceptions of an institution’s whiteness rather than the whiteness of the organisation itself.
For Creative Arts Social, belonging means people are recognised, trusted, cared for and able to exercise agency without suppressing parts of themselves or conforming to dominant cultural norms in order to be safe, heard or valued. It is harder to measure because it describes an experience of power as much as inclusion. It asks whether expertise is genuinely trusted and whether people can challenge decisions or speak up without fearing damage to their position. The fact that so many people who experience workplace racism (7) do not report it makes that question especially important.
Crucially, the institutional norms people are being asked to navigate are not neutral. Ideas of “professionalism”, “best practice” or simply “the way things are done here” often encode Eurocentric assumptions about whose behaviour, knowledge and ways of working are considered legitimate. Again, that Broken Ladders finding that 61% of women of colour changed aspects of themselves to fit in is particularly revealing here. An institution can therefore diversify who enters it without changing whose values continue to define it, or who has to adapt in order to progress within it.
Creative Arts Social works with the realities of Eurocentric organisational culture across the sector. We help organisations move beyond statements of inclusion, representation, anti-racism and social justice, and beyond a narrow focus on outputs, towards embedding positive transformation in everyday practice and processes. This means building equity, accountability, care, decolonial methodologies, agency and anti-racist practice throughout the organisation, supported by clear accountability structures and evaluative methods that test whether change is meaningful and lasting. Kikuchi’s presence could be counted as representation, but her account of being “the only non-white person in the room” reveals something else: who is present tells us little unless we also ask whose authority changes decisions and who is still required to conform.
Kikuchi’s experience is not isolated. Barbican Stories (12) gathered 98 accounts of discrimination from current and former employees after staff dissatisfaction with the institution’s response to Black Lives Matter. In 2021, Historic Royal Palaces (13) reportedly made confidential settlements following staff complaints of bullying and racial discrimination. Jade Montserrat’s experience (14), including Tate’s refusal to include her in a Tate Exchange programme, exposed a similar gap between public commitments and the treatment of a Black artist challenging institutional power. Alleged racial profiling during a 2025 school visit to the V&A (15) raised the issue again. The intense media scrutiny preceding Professor Jason Arday’s resignation (9) from Cambridge and unexpected death extends these questions of care, accountability and belonging into academia and the media.
Representation matters, and retreating from diversity commitments is not the answer, but it is only one measure. Counting who enters an institution or becomes visible cannot show how power operates once people are inside. Diversity tells us who is in the room; belonging asks who can shape it, who is expected to adapt, who decides who is invited in and who can redesign it. These accounts reveal not an incomplete form of belonging but its absence: people may be present and visible while remaining unsupported, unheard and structurally unable to change the institution around them.
Endnotes
1. Sarvy Geranpayeh, The Art Newspaper, ‘Head of V&A’s academic programmes resigned citing “racist” and “culturally insensitive” behaviours, letter reveals’, 2026.
2. Tristram Hunt, V&A Blog, ‘Black Lives Matter: Race and Equality at the V&A’, 2020.
3. KUOW, ‘The backstory of how #BlackOutTuesday became a thing’, 2020.
4. Nesrine Malik, The Guardian, ‘The Black Lives Matter era is over. It taught us the limits of diversity for diversity’s sake’, 2024.
5. Sara Ahmed, ‘The Nonperformativity of Antiracism’, Meridians, 7(1), 2006, pp. 104–126.
6. Fawcett Society and Runnymede Trust, Broken Ladders: The Myth of Meritocracy for Women of Colour in the Workplace, 2022.
7. Trades Union Congress, ‘2 in 5 BME workers experience racism at work—new TUC report’, 2022.
8. Olúfẹ́mi O. Táíwò, Boston Review, ‘Identity Politics and Elite Capture’, 2020.
9. Sally Weale, The Guardian, ‘Jason Arday, professor at centre of Cambridge plagiarism row, found dead’, 2026.
10. Bridget Byrne and Roaa Ali, ‘The Endurance of Whiteness in a Museum’, The Sociological Review, 2025.
11. Tate, Diversity and Inclusion.
12. Barbican Stories, 2021.
13. Amelia Gentleman, The Guardian, ‘Historic Royal Palaces settles bullying and racial discrimination complaints’, 2021.
14. Cristina Ruiz, The Art Newspaper, ‘Meet Jade Montserrat, the Black artist who took on the British art establishment’, 2021.
15. BBC News, ‘V&A accused of racially profiling pupils during school visit’, 2025.



